- Tickets. Get the best tickets for NFL games at Tickets MARCA
- Pittsburgh Steelers. Ben Roethlisberger's insight on Steelers coaching search sparks discussion
Mike Tomlin's resignation has pushed the Pittsburgh Steelers into unfamiliar territory, forcing a head coaching search that feels almost foreign for a franchise built on continuity.
With Tomlin stepping aside, the Steelers are preparing to name only their fourth head coach since 1969, a moment that has triggered serious reflection about whether the club's long-standing approach still fits the modern NFL.
Tomlin leaves behind an extraordinary legacy. Over 19 seasons, he never produced a losing record, a level of consistency few coaches can match.
Yet the other side of the picture is harder to ignore. Pittsburgh has not won a playoff game since 2016, and in recent years the team has often looked stuck between competitiveness and contention. For many observers, Tomlin's exit feels less like upheaval and more like a natural breaking point.
No voice carries more credibility on this subject than Ben Roethlisberger, who spent his entire career in Pittsburgh, overlapping with Tomlin from 2007 until his retirement in 2022.
Speaking on a recent episode of his show, Channel Seven, Roethlisberger was direct about what he would prioritise if he were making the decision himself.
"My first thought is, I want an offensive-minded head coach," he said. "That's what I would do if I was the general manager. We had defensive-minded coaches, that's what they've all been, I'm ready for an offensive guy, I wanna score more than six points in an offseason game. I would love a younger head coach, a McVay-ish."
A rare opportunity to rethink the Steelers' identity
Roethlisberger's comments reflect a broader reality around the league. The NFL has shifted decisively toward creative, aggressive offences, while Pittsburgh has remained rooted in a defence-first identity.
This season, the Steelers ranked 14th in PFSN's NFL Offense Impact Metric, respectable but well short of elite, reinforcing the sense that the ceiling has been too low.
One name that fits Roethlisberger's vision is Nathan Scheelhaase, currently the pass game coordinator for the Los Angeles Rams.
Scheelhaase represents the younger, modern offensive profile Roethlisberger referenced, shaped within a system known for innovation and quarterback development.
If that option proves premature, Roethlisberger also pointed to a more familiar, experienced figure.
"My next choice would literally be Mike McCarthy. An offensive veteran with Pittsburgh ties, he understands the Steeler way, the Rooney family and how it works. He could bring a younger coordinator to help. The downside for this is how long he wants to coach," Roethlisberger said.
McCarthy's name has already circulated in league discussions, and his history as an offensive coach would signal a clear philosophical shift, even if it raises questions about long-term planning.
The final candidate Roethlisberger mentioned was Brian Flores, whom he called a "great coach." Even then, he made it clear that Flores would represent a compromise rather than his ideal scenario, reiterating his preference for an offensive background at the top.