Biggest college football snub? Fans react to Jeremiah Smith missing out on Biletnikoff

When the winner of the 2025 Biletnikoff Award was announced, the college football world expected a celebration of elite receiving talent.

Instead, the spotlight quickly shifted to Ohio State star Jeremiah Smith after he failed to take home the hardware. USC's Makai Lemon claimed the honor, but social media erupted with debates and disbelief over what some are calling one of the biggest snubs in recent memory.

Jeremiah Smith's season was nothing short of remarkable. He finished with 80 receptions for 1,086 yards and 11 touchdowns, averaging 90.5 yards per game. Statistically, he ranked tied for sixth nationally in receptions and touchdowns and seventh in receiving yards.

This came after a breakout freshman year in 2024, when he led the Big Ten with 76 catches for 1,315 yards and 15 touchdowns, helping Ohio State secure a national championship. Smith's production and impact on the field made him a natural contender for the award and fueled high expectations among fans and analysts alike.

Meanwhile, Makai Lemon also had a strong season. He recorded 79 catches for 1,156 yards and 11 touchdowns, excelling in advanced metrics and earning top grades from Pro Football Focus.

While Lemon's credentials were impressive, the contrast between him and Smith, particularly Smith's established dominance and postseason contributions, made the decision controversial to many observers.

Fans and the fallout

The reaction on social media was swift and passionate. Fans expressed disbelief, frustration, and even outrage. One post called the outcome "the biggest robbery in college football history," while others simply stated, "Jeremiah Smith robbed."

The sentiment didn't just reflect disappointment. It was also a deep skepticism of the selection process itself, though some suggested that this perceived slight could set the stage for an even more extraordinary postseason run from Smith.

Interestingly, Smith didn't directly comment on losing the award. Instead, he shared a clip from the movie Paid in Full, which insiders interpreted as a signal of motivation rather than frustration.

With the College Football Playoff on the horizon, many see this as a subtle way of refocusing energy toward the next challenge.

Not winning the Biletnikoff Award may come as a disappointment for Smith. However, as he looks to help Ohio State claim another national title, he may get the final laugh should he add the biggest prize in college football to his growing list of accomplishments.